Best alternatives for InsureBooster Order Protection Shopify app in 2026 [Updated]
PickYourApp Review Team
6 min read
•
Nov 16, 2025
Protect your business and customers with essential warranty and insurance solutions for Shopify stores. From in-house shipping protection and extended warranties to product registration systems, these apps help you manage risks, increase revenue, and build customer trust. Whether you need shipping insurance alternatives, accident protection, or warranty registration tools, you'll find apps that let you offer peace of mind while creating new profit opportunities through upsells and revenue sharing.
-
#1. Shipping protection that boosts revenue. Order protection reduces damage, loss, theft risks.
Captain Shipping Protection offers a complete order protection solution for your Shopify store. This app lets you provide shipping protection directly at checkout, without relying on third-party insurance providers. You collect all protection fees and manage claims according to your policy, creating an additional revenue stream. The user-friendly widget integrates smoothly with your store through app blocks, supporting multiple languages and customizable pricing options. Whether you're handling single orders or subscriptions, the app helps secure packages against damage, loss, or theft while increasing your profits. Switch from your current protection provider and start offering package assurance to your customers today - all without adding any extra code to your store theme.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#2. Protect customers’ purchases in transit and use, earn their loyalty, & profit through revenue share!
Offer your customers complete peace of mind with extended warranty and shipping insurance protection plans. SureBright seamlessly integrates product protection into your checkout process, covering accidental damage, drops, and liquid spills across 50+ product categories. Earn additional revenue through profit sharing while building customer trust and loyalty. The platform handles all financial risks, customer service, and claims processing - with simple 5-minute online claim filing and 24/7 support. Customize the protection plans and interface to match your brand perfectly. Get started quickly with real-time revenue tracking and transparent reporting, turning product mishaps into positive customer experiences.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#3. Add shipping protection, rush orders, warranty, donations, upsells, bundles, and more with one cart!
Supercart helps online stores increase sales and order values through smart cart customization. Built with four years of e-commerce expertise, this app lets you add essential features like shipping protection, rush ordering, product warranties, and charitable donations - all in one cart. Create compelling upsells, bundle offers, and AI-driven product recommendations while maintaining full control over your cart's design. With easy A/B testing and unlimited customization options, you can build a unique shopping experience that matches your brand and drives conversions. The familiar editor makes it simple to implement cart features that build customer trust and encourage larger purchases through strategic incentives and free gift offers.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#4. Your own Shipping protection to offset costs of Lost, Damaged or Stolen orders and build buyer trust
Take control of your shipping protection program and let customers insure their orders directly through your store. This customizable solution helps offset costs from damaged, lost, or stolen packages while building customer confidence. Set tiered insurance rates based on cart value, display protection options at checkout, and keep all insurance revenue within your business. The fully customizable widget appears seamlessly on cart, checkout, and thank you pages, supporting multiple languages and currencies. Customers get peace of mind knowing their shipments are protected, while you maintain complete control over the protection program's terms and pricing. Unlike third-party providers, you retain all insurance profits when claims are low - which is typically the case. Note: This is a shipping protection program, not an insurance provider service.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#5. Boost revenue and trust with branded order protection, free returns, and instant resolutions.
Protect your customers' orders while creating a new revenue stream with SHIPAID's comprehensive shipping protection solution. The platform lets you manage lost, damaged, or stolen packages through an easy-to-use dashboard while keeping protection fees as profit. Customers enjoy peace of mind with branded order tracking, free returns, and quick claim resolutions through a dedicated portal. The built-in Returns Management System simplifies exchanges and returns processing. Every protected order makes a positive impact by planting a tree and contributing $5 to your customer's preferred charity, helping build lasting trust and loyalty. Offer complete order protection that benefits both your business and customers.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#6. Offer customers accident protection and extended warranties
Protect your customers' purchases with Mulberry's comprehensive product protection and extended warranty solution. The app's smart AI system automatically identifies eligible items in your catalog and suggests suitable warranty coverage. Customers can easily add protection plans while shopping on product pages, during checkout, or even after purchase. With customizable widgets that match your store's design, offering product protection becomes seamless. When accidents happen, customers can quickly submit claims through Mulberry's automated online portal. The entire process, from protection plan purchase to claim filing, is handled directly by Mulberry, giving you and your customers peace of mind with reliable product coverage.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#7. Upsell premium services at checkout: increase AOV and improve customer experience
Increase your average order value by offering premium services right at checkout with ProtectMyOrder. This easy-to-setup app lets you sell valuable add-ons like shipping protection, carbon neutral delivery, and free returns directly to customers during their purchase. With full control over pricing, text, and visuals, you can customize the entire experience to match your brand. Test the impact by showing these premium services to 50% of your traffic. The best part? You retain 80% of all upsell revenue while managing claims in-house. Get started with just 9 clicks and create new revenue streams through customer-focused checkout services.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#8. Warranty app for Product Registrations, Capture 1st-Party Data, Manage Claims, and Support Requests.
Dyrect simplifies warranty management for Shopify merchants by automating product registrations, warranty claims, and customer support requests. This warranty app helps you capture first-party customer data from multiple channels including Shopify orders, retail stores, and other e-commerce platforms. Customers can easily register products through customizable web forms and emails, then access a self-serve portal to track their warranties and file claims. The app sends automated email notifications and generates digital warranty certificates to keep customers informed. Set up takes under 20 minutes with automatic Shopify product sync. Manage your omnichannel customers from one platform while delivering helpful product guides, tutorials, and accessory recommendations. Built-in analytics provide insights into warranty registrations and claims. Contact support to enable advanced claims management features and custom branding options.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#9. Umbrella enables merchants to sell and manage extended warranties and protection plans 100% in house
Sell and manage extended warranties and protection plans directly through your Shopify store without third-party providers. Create custom warranty plans that display automatically on product pages, cart, checkout, and post-purchase pages. Your customers can submit claims through a built-in form that connects to their order history. The app includes white-label protection plans, automated claims processing, and a self-service customer portal - all operating under your own rules and rates. Track performance with detailed analytics and use AI-powered fraud detection to auto-approve eligible claims. Keep full control of your warranty program, customer data, and profit margins while providing an AppleCare-style protection experience.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#10. The complete post-purchase platform: tracking, returns, shipping protection, warranty & registration
Corso is your complete post-purchase platform that brings tracking, returns, exchanges, shipping protection, and warranty management into one unified solution. The platform features branded customer portals, automated return processing, and comprehensive warranty claim handling with product registration. Manage your post-purchase operations efficiently with performance-based pricing, no contracts, and professional onboarding support. Corso integrates seamlessly with leading CX platforms, 3PL providers, and shipping services. The built-in BI tools give you clear insights into return rates and warranty claims. Let our Corso Concierge team handle WISMO inquiries while you focus on growth. With world-class human support and flexible automation options, you can create customer-focused post-purchase experiences that work for your brand.Install from Shopify App Store