Best Package insurance Shopify apps in 2026 [Updated]
PickYourApp Review Team
6 min read
•
Dec 03, 2025
The best Shopify package insurance apps help merchants protect shipments while generating additional revenue through shipping protection programs. From in-house shipping protection alternatives to percentage-based insurance plans, these solutions let store owners offer premium protection services at checkout. Whether you're looking to manage your own protection program or provide customers with comprehensive tracking and insurance options, these top-rated apps deliver essential tools for secure order fulfillment and improved customer confidence.
-
#1. Shipping Protection and Order Protection managed by you. Keep package protection revenue as profit.
Manage your own shipping protection program and keep 100% of the protection fees as profit with Navidium. This self-service platform lets you offer package protection at checkout while maintaining full control over pricing and claims. The built-in claims portal makes handling customer requests simple with one-click refunds and reorders. Compatible with major Shopify tools including Recharge, Rebuy, Bold, Slide Cart, Subscriptions, and Tapcart, Navidium seamlessly adds shipping protection options to your store. Track performance through detailed reporting while building a self-funded protection program that generates additional revenue. Note: Navidium provides the platform to manage shipping protection - we are not an insurance provider and do not underwrite plans. Use our tools to create protection offerings, process claims, and retain all collected fees instead of paying third-party insurance providers.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#2. Add shipping protection, manage claims easily, and boost revenue with full fee control.
Protect your shipments and build customer confidence with Insureful's shipping protection service. This easy-to-use app lets you offer insurance coverage against theft and damage, with flexible pricing options including percentage-based or fixed-rate plans. Set minimum and maximum cart limits while maintaining full control over fees. The app seamlessly integrates into your cart and checkout pages, supporting multiple languages and currencies. When claims arise, manage them efficiently through automated fulfillment options including store credit, reorders, or full refunds. Orders with insurance are automatically tagged for easy tracking. Perfect for merchants wanting to provide additional purchase protection while creating a new revenue stream. The customizable widget fits naturally into your store's design, making insurance offerings clear and accessible to customers.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#3. Upsell premium services at checkout: increase AOV and improve customer experience
Increase your average order value by offering premium services right at checkout with ProtectMyOrder. This easy-to-setup app lets you sell valuable add-ons like shipping protection, carbon neutral delivery, and free returns directly to customers during their purchase. With full control over pricing, text, and visuals, you can customize the entire experience to match your brand. Test the impact by showing these premium services to 50% of your traffic. The best part? You retain 80% of all upsell revenue while managing claims in-house. Get started with just 9 clicks and create new revenue streams through customer-focused checkout services.Install from Shopify App Store
-
#4. Simple Shipping Insurance, Protection, and Upsells to Increase Trust and AOV.
Add shipping protection to your store and increase revenue while building customer trust. This simple checkout widget lets you offer branded order insurance with complete control over pricing tiers. You keep 100% of protection fees without involving third-party insurers. Manage claims efficiently through a dedicated dashboard that tracks and resolves customer issues. The customizable protection widget integrates seamlessly with your checkout, improving the shopping experience while increasing average order value. Perfect for stores looking to provide peace of mind to customers while creating an additional revenue stream.Install from Shopify App Store