Redirecting every 404 error to your homepage creates a poor user experience, confuses search engines, and can harm your website's search rankings. This blanket redirect approach sends mixed signals to search engine crawlers and leaves visitors disoriented when they expect specific content but arrive at a generic homepage.
The Doc 404 Shopify app helps you create targeted, relevant redirects instead of homepage redirects. The app suggests appropriate destinations based on the broken URL, ensuring visitors reach helpful content.
Why Homepage Redirects Harm Your Store
User confusion increases dramatically when visitors click a link expecting a specific product and land on your homepage with no explanation. This disorienting experience leads to high bounce rates as frustrated users simply leave your site. Studies show approximately 74% of users who encounter navigation issues will abandon the site immediately.
Search engine crawlers interpret blanket homepage redirects as "soft 404" errors. When Google follows a broken backlink and gets redirected to your homepage, it recognizes this as a non-existent page rather than a legitimate redirect. This wastes crawl budget as the search engine continues attempting to recrawl the broken URL.
Link equity disappears when external backlinks to specific product pages get redirected to your homepage. The homepage cannot serve as a relevant replacement for a specific product, so search engines do not pass the full SEO value. This wasted link equity represents lost ranking potential for your store.
Tracking broken links becomes impossible when every 404 redirects to the homepage. You lose visibility into which internal links are broken, which external sites are sending traffic to dead URLs, and where your site structure needs repair. This hidden technical debt accumulates over time.
Proper Redirect Strategies
Create specific 301 redirects for pages that have moved. When you delete a product and have a similar replacement, redirect the old product URL to the new product page. If you discontinue an entire collection, redirect those product pages to the parent category or a related collection where visitors can find alternatives.
Maintain 404 status for genuinely non-existent pages. When content is permanently removed with no suitable replacement, serving a proper 404 error page is the correct approach. Create a custom 404 page that includes a search bar, links to popular products, and navigation to key sections of your store.
Read more:
